Because I Said So – Dad Edition – Too Fat To Fly

by BuckDaddy on February 22, 2010

For this week’s Because I Said So, MommaDJane and I are going to discuss: Should people of size have to buy an extra seat on airplanes.

Unless you are living under a rock, you probably heard about Kevin Smith‘s (director of Clerks, Mallrats, and Cop Out) and his problems of being Too Fat To Fly by Southwest airlines.  It is being referred to as FatGate, or ChubbtGate.  Huffington Post has a good review of who was right and wrong.  If you want to decide for yourself you can review Kevin Smith’s tweets, Southwest first response and second response and Smith’s responses to all that.

You may be wondering why we picked this topic for Because I Said So.  Well, MommaDJane is normal sized person or as I like to call them, small.  As you may or may not know, I am 6’5″ and about 300 lbs.  I don’t fit on planes.  Heck, I don’t fit in most cars.  The first thing people say when I get in the passenger seat of their car is, “I think that goes back some.” It usually doesn’t.  It is even worse on planes.

I only fly when it is a necessity.  I almost opted at my last job to drive from Memphis to Tulsa because it was only 8 hours but it was cheaper to fly.  When I do fly, I take precautions.  I book early and I sit on the emergency exit or the bulkhead seat.  Sometimes no matter what I do, I have to fly and sit in a regular seat.  Let me tell you it is not fun for anyone near me.  The person in front of me can’t put their seat back.  The person next to me has my legs spilling over into their foot space (I have long legs) and help us all if I sit in a window seat and have to pee during the flight.

With all that said, I do however fit in a regular seat.  I would but upset if I had to buy an additional seat to fly.  Also I would be really mad if I was already in my seat and they kicked me off and sited that I didn’t fit and needed to buy a second seat but there were no seats available to buy.  The problem, in my opinion, is the airlines are trying to squeeze as many people on to one plane as possible.  To top that all off, the airlines have started the practice of over selling the flights.  This practice was thought up because an empty seat is wasted money.

Do I think bigger people should have to buy an extra seat? Should you be kicked off a flight because you are bigger? NO!  I think the airlines should be a smaller number of seats and larger seats on the plane.  I don’t have to buy a second seat, yet.  To me it is a slippery slope and only a matter of time before they tell me I am too tall to fly.

What do you think of the whole Kevin Smith/Southwest fight?  Should larger people be required to buy additional seats?

I think that MommaDJane might have a different opinion on it all because she is normal sized and probably dreads seeing me lumber down the aisle about to sit down next to her on a plane.  I am heading over to MommaDJane to check hers out but it might take me a minute because I am so large.  Why don’t you join me?

Have a topic or question you would like to hear our views on? Have you always wanted to hear both sides of a topic or answers to a question, unbiased? You can submit topics or questions via comments or even anonymously to buckrogers79@gmail.com. We will pick questions at random and blog on one topic per week.


You might also enjoy these posts:

Post Footer automatically generated by Add Post Footer Plugin for wordpress.

  • Delicious
  • Facebook
  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Twitter

{ 8 comments }

BenSpark February 22, 2010 at 11:23 am

I listen to Kevin Smith’s SMODCast and I was up on what was happening. While the actual reason was not because he was fat, it was because he was the last on the plane. The Southwest employees there dropped the ball. Sure Kevin over reacted on twitter. He really did. However he was not unjustified in his outrage. I like that he had Smodcast 107 which featured the young woman who sat next to him on the flight that he did get on.

I used to fly often and there are some people of size who cannot fit in one regular seat with the armrests down. When they are spilling over into the seats around them then this is a problem for the comfort of the other passengers. I’m not a little person. I’m 5’10″ 230lbs. I carry some extra weight, right up front. I can however fold myself into the smallest possible space for the duration of most flights, which I often have to do when someone next to me spills into my seat. Planes need to be made to have some bigger seats. Everything on a plane is too small; tempers, overhead space and the like.
.-= BenSpark´s last blog ..Wii got The Touch =-.

Cat February 22, 2010 at 11:25 am

Fair warning, you won’t like my response.

Do I think people of a larger size (that infringe on the space of adjacent passengers) should have to buy an extra seat?
Yes

Do I think airlines should reduce the number of seats and upgrade their size to accommodate larger people?
absolutely Not.

Do I think airlines should offer seating for taller than average people
Yes.

A person’s width and weight is something they created, someone’s leg length obviously isn’t. Why should airlines redo their planes, costing millions if not billions of dollars, imposing rate hikes on the majority of customers that have no problems fitting in the current seats?
.-= Cat´s last blog ..Creating Normalcy with Sunday Brunch =-.

MommaDJane February 22, 2010 at 12:27 pm

Good points! I think we mostly agree. I tried to look at both sides, I truly did. But I must say I would NEVER have guessed you were 300 pounds. I know you are big but you are so tall that is seems very proportionate. I have never been bothered sitting next to a larger person. However I am small enough that I can move over in my own seat to never even notice. I do understand it is a problem and if the solution of re-making all planes was realistic then that’s what I would say do. I hate driving long ways because flying is so much faster so I hate that you have to deal with that. It’s truly not fair, in my opinion.
.-= MommaDJane´s last blog ..Because I Said So – Mom Edition =-.

BuckDaddy March 1, 2010 at 1:27 am

Thanks. Yeah I carry my weight well but still uncofortamble flying

Erica Mueller February 22, 2010 at 1:41 pm

Dwan is so tiny you could fit two of her in a normal sized seat, and she’d still have room. :-)

My mother in-law is a large woman. For her birthday last year we flew her north to see her family… we had to buy her a first class ticket, or we would have had to purchase two normal seats. It ended up being about the same price and we knew she’d be more comfortable in one seat that she actually fit in, than straddling two.

I know airlines need to make money, but we’re already paying major fees to fly + baggage fees, and if they don’t do something soon, everyone will start driving! Maybe the seats need to be a little bigger?

LOL @ airlines charging you more cause you’re too tall. My husband is 6′ 3″ and his brother is 6′ 5″. they pretty much beg for the aisle seats for the extra legroom and to avoid the ducking and folding of their bodies that would have to take place to get to a window seat. haha

What kind of car do your drive?
.-= Erica Mueller´s last blog ..ChevyBliss – The Equinox Roadtrip and Review =-.

BuckDaddy March 1, 2010 at 1:25 am

I drive a ford ranger but at one time drove a geo metro

J.R. Reed February 25, 2010 at 9:23 pm

Totally good question dude. I am on the fence when it comes to this one. For the most part I think that they shouldn’t have to buy a second seat, but on the other hand I don’t want to be crammed because the person next to me is spilling into my seat.

Don’t think I’m all against people that are fat, because I’m not. Some people have no choice and are that way no matter what they do while others are just lazy asses who have a love affair with Ben, Jerry and their couch.

The bottom line? I don’t know what I think, but I like what you said…
.-= J.R. Reed´s last blog ..Breaking up: “How To” & “How Not To” =-.

BuckDaddy March 1, 2010 at 1:24 am

I see your point

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post:

Next post: